Building Forever Families
One Child at a Time
Schedule a Consultation Today
Happy family with adopted child
The Law Office of Karen M. Holman June 27, 2024

Open vs Closed Adoption

Adoption is a beautiful way to grow your family and provide a loving home for a child, but the journey comes with many decisions. One of the most significant choices prospective parents face is whether to pursue an open or closed adoption.  

As an adoption attorney at The Law Office of Karen M. Holman, PLLC, in Winchester, Virginia, I have supported many clients through these impactful decisions. Understanding the differences between open and closed adoption can help you decide what's best for your family and your future child's well-being. 

What Is Open Adoption?

Open adoption is a form of adoption where there is some level of ongoing contact between the adoptive family and the birth parents. This contact can range from periodic updates and photos to regular in-person visits, depending on the agreement between both parties.

The primary aim is to maintain a relationship that benefits the child by providing a sense of identity and connection to their biological heritage. 

The process of open adoption typically begins with an adoption agency or family law attorney facilitating initial meetings and discussions between prospective adoptive parents and birth parents. These preliminary interactions help set the foundation for mutual trust and understanding.

During this time, both parties can discuss their expectations, form an adoption plan, and agree on the level and frequency of contact post-adoption. Legal parameters are then established to ensure that the agreed-upon level of openness is maintained, and both parties are clear on their roles and responsibilities. 

Common Benefits of Open Adoption: 

  1. Open adoption offers significant emotional benefits for the child, providing a greater understanding of their background and reassuring them that their birth parents' decision was made out of love. 

  1. Being able to access the birth family's medical history is crucial for the child’s healthcare needs and helps anticipate and manage potential hereditary issues. 

  1. Birth parents gain peace of mind knowing about their child's well-being and maintaining a relationship, which aids in their healing process. 

  1. Open adoption has the power to foster a trusting relationship between the adoptive and birth families, creating a broader support network for the child. 

Potential Drawbacks of Open Adoption 

  1. The ongoing relationship between the adoptive family and birth parents can sometimes become complex and emotionally challenging, requiring clear boundaries and open communication. 

  2. Differences in parenting styles or expectations regarding the level of contact can sometimes lead to misunderstandings or conflicts

  3. Maintaining an open adoption requires a level of shared privacy that some families may find uncomfortable or invasive

  4. Both the child and the adoptive parents may experience emotional challenges as they navigate their unique family structure and the presence of the child's birth parents in their lives. 

With careful planning, clear communication, and mutual respect, open adoption can be a fulfilling and enriching experience that enhances the well-being of everyone involved, particularly the child at the center of it all. 

What Is Closed Adoption?

In contrast, closed adoption maintains privacy and separation between the birth and adoptive families. Once the adoption is finalized, there is no further contact, and all identifying information is kept confidential. The adoptive parents and the child receive no information beyond what is required by law, which typically includes basic medical history. 

The process of closed adoption starts similarly to that of open adoption, with prospective parents working with an adoption agency or attorney to find a suitable match. However, once the match is made, the interactions between the birth and adoptive parents are minimal or nonexistent.

The birth parents typically provide the necessary legal paperwork and medical history, preserving the anonymity of all parties involved. The adoption is finalized in court, where the adoptive parents are granted full legal rights and responsibilities for the child. Post-adoption, the records are sealed, and there is no further contact between the birth and adoptive families. 

Common Benefits of Closed Adoption: 

  1. Closed adoption offers a clear boundary between the birth and adoptive families, which some people find emotionally safer and more manageable. 

  2. Without the ongoing interactions required in open adoption, the relationship dynamics are simpler, reducing the potential for conflicts or misunderstandings

  3. By not maintaining a connection to the birth parents, adoptive families can concentrate more fully on their relationships within the new family unit. 

  4. The sealed records ensure that birth parents' and adoptive parents' privacy is maintained, which can be particularly important in cases where anonymity is crucial. 

Potential Challenges of Closed Adoption: 

  1. Adopted children may feel a void in their identity or struggle with questions about their origins, as they do not have the opportunity to know their birth parents. 

  2. The adoptive family may have access to only a limited, basic medical history, which could impede healthcare decisions and preparation for potential hereditary conditions. 

  3. Birth parents may experience a heavier emotional toll due to the complete lack of information about their child's well-being post-adoption, which could hinder their healing process. 

  4. As adopted children grow older, they might want to seek out their birth parents, which could be challenging and emotionally fraught due to the sealed records. 

The choice between open and closed adoption is deeply personal and should be made after careful consideration of all factors involved. Both forms of adoption offer the potential for a loving, stable home for a child, but the differences in how relationships are managed post-adoption can significantly impact everyone involved. 

Which Path Is Right for You? 

Choosing between open and closed adoption is deeply personal and complex. As your attorney, I believe it's vital to weigh the potential impacts carefully and consider both your family’s needs and the future well-being of your child.  

Open adoptions can provide invaluable connections and cultural continuity, but they require a commitment to ongoing interaction. Closed adoptions offer privacy and finality but may leave gaps in the child's understanding of their origins. 

Why Legal Counsel Is Essential

Open adoptions, in particular, need well-drafted agreements to define the extent and nature of ongoing contact and protect the rights and expectations of all parties involved. Even in closed adoptions, it's crucial to ensure all legal procedures are followed meticulously to prevent any future disputes.  

An experienced adoption attorney can guide you through any legalities or processes and help you make informed decisions that are in the best interest of your child. 

Speak With a Virginia Adoption Lawyer

At The Law Office of Karen M. Holman, PLLC, I provide comprehensive legal support throughout your adoption journey. Whether you choose open or closed adoption, I will help you craft agreements that safeguard your family's future. 

By understanding the differences and implications of open versus closed adoption, you are better equipped to make decisions that will shape your family's future for the better. Should you need legal assistance, please contact my Winchester office.

Together, we can pave a clearer, smoother pathway to parenthood. I’m proud to work with families throughout Northern Virginia and the Shenandoah Valley including Harrisonburg, Staunton, Woodstock, Strasburg, and Stephens City. 


Open vs Closed Adoption  -

Adoption is a beautiful way to grow your family and provide a loving home for a child, but the journey comes with many decisions. One of the most significant choices prospective parents face is whether to pursue an open or closed adoption.

Read More
Assisted Reproduction in the Post-Dobbs Era  -

In my years of practicing law, I've seen many legal changes and their impacts on the lives of my clients. One such change is the Dobbs ruling which has the potential to affect assisted reproductive technologies (ART), particularly in vitro fertilization (IVF).

Read More